Canada Free Press -- ARCHIVES

Because without America, there is no free world.

Return to Canada Free Press

Cover Story

addressing the Propaganda against School Choice

Nancy Salvato,

December 20, 2004

according to the author of Privatization Zealotry (www.educationnews.org/privatization-zealotry.htm), Marty Solomon, the only way to make a major improvement in our educational system is NOT through privatization. He believes there is NOT any one answer to the problems in the public school system, regardless of how beneficial independent administration might prove. This is because he feels that NO school can adequately address the socio/economic situations that reflect a certain percentage of students who make up the attendance in any one school.

But schools CaN address certain socio-economic disadvantages, depending on how they are structured. For instance, I just read about a school, the academy of alternatives (www.oregonlive.com/metroeast/oregonian/index.ssf?/base/metro_east_news/110311540793950.xml), which, "is accredited for special, alternative and private education." The school is broadening its focus to include, "drug and alcohol education, anger management, conflict-resolution, and life skills." What caught my attention is that there are five students per classroom! This benefits the students because of the individualized instructional setting. In addition, students need only attend school for three hours to get credit for a full day of school. Hours usually reserved for school can be used to work and earn income or get medical or special-education services. Professionals trained to deal with socio/economic concerns can be utilized to address any "baggage" these children are carrying. By contrast, the one size fits all nature of the public school system makes this type of personal attentiveness impossible in the traditional educational setting.

Next, Mr. Solomon says that the demographics of a private school influence academic performance. This is because kids from wealthier families attend these schools and kids who misbehave can be kicked out. However, a study issued by the London School of Economics and Political Science clearly suggests that family income determines access to the best schools, including state schools. It’s irrelevant whether the school is paid for by taxes or independently. The neighborhood in which a family resides is the most accurate indicator of the local school’s quality. a school’s quality is best reflected in local house prices.

The argument that Edison Charter Schools haven’t performed nearly as well as their proponents claimed they would, due to their independent status is really inconsequential. Because they are independently run, if they fail, they close. They do not perpetuate the status quo failure which exemplifies many public schools.

Yes, NCLB has raised the standards and thrust high expectations on the public school system. It was set up this way to address decades of gross negligence thrust upon those who had to endure the "bigotry of low expectations"; those unable to pursue alternative education because they could not afford to pay twice for school (once in taxes for public education and once for tuition). according to andrew Coulson, (www.theoaklandpress.com/stories/121204/opi_20041212013.shtml) "Our high school seniors and recent graduates perform abysmally on international tests of mathematics, science and literacy."

In the interest of fairness to those of school age, forced to endure the public school system because their families are unable to afford alternative education, we must break the status quo by allowing our students to pursue an alternative means to an education with tuition tax credit refunds and tuition scholarships which help to cover the cost of the most appropriate education available. Only in this way will the schools not longer be enabled and held unaccountable for their failures to address the decline of our schools.


Pursuant to Title 17 U.S.C. 107, other copyrighted work is provided for educational purposes, research, critical comment, or debate without profit or payment. If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for your own purposes beyond the 'fair use' exception, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner. Views are those of authors and not necessarily those of Canada Free Press. Content is Copyright 1997-2024 the individual authors. Site Copyright 1997-2024 Canada Free Press.Com Privacy Statement